The better and the worst puzzle

[gustavopi]

I'm curious about your opinion! I still didn't play most of the series, but I'll put my thoughts just for the beginning:

Better: SM, computer of school's director: very fanny searching for clues in the director's stuffs! Also his life (including his ex) became a part of the story.

Worst: SM, gumball machine: the idea is good, but the colors are not really like the mascot. Tuck me hours turning the analog control and hundreds of balls! Ok, now I take note of the right colors...

[what]

I hate the coin puzzle in Silent Hill 2. No matter how many times I played the game, I could never, ever remember the correct answer and the clues, even on Easy, didn't make sense to me.

[gustavopi]

I hate the coin puzzle in Silent Hill 2. No matter how many times I played the game, I could never, ever remember the correct answer and the clues, even on Easy, didn't make sense to me.

Is that so? I was thinking my english was not good enough to understand the poetry and solve the mystery. But ironically the last times I'd pick some terms from the text and could find the right places for the coins without consulting gamefaqs. Maybe luck, maybe fate...

[OneFreeMan]

For me the best are: Grim Reaper's List - SH1
Light Puzzle - SH1
Free the Innocent Man - SH2
Music Box Puzzle - SH2
Anatomy Puzzle - SH:O
Church Organ Puzzle - SH:H

And the worst: Shepherd Emblem Puzzle - SH:H
Founding Families Puzzle - SH:H
Valve Puzzle - SH1
Rotating Cube Puzzle - SH2

[TraceBASS]

I've only thus far played Silent Hill 2 and some of Silent Hill. That said, I liked the Music Box puzzle the best, and the Coin puzzle the least. Purely because I forgot a coin, and had to backtrack a hefty way to grab it.

[gustavopi]

I've only thus far played Silent Hill 2 and some of Silent Hill. That said, I liked the Music Box puzzle the best, and the Coin puzzle the least. Purely because I forgot a coin, and had to backtrack a hefty way to grab it.

I forgot a coin in the first time too, and I also didn't find the map of second building... hard working!

[Perry Mason]

Better: Anatomy Puzzle (Silent Hill: Origins)
Worst: Valve Puzzle (Silent Hill)

[rollerfan222]

Best:
Crematorium puzzle - SH3
Organ puzzle - Homecoming
Otherworld Prison puzzle - Homecoming
Wire puzzle at Hotel (cause the clue was in your nose and could be very easy to figure out) - Homecoming
Tarot card puzzle - SH3

Worst:
Attic puzzle - Homecoming (Spent almost 2 fucking hours, i almost pulled my hair out)
Cube - SH2
Safes - Downpour
Founding families - Homecoming (easy, but the speed of the circles was frustrating)


That's what i can remember right now.

[gustavopi]

This worst puzzles are because the difficult level, or you don't like it? The cube is a little annoying in the first place, but when you can imagine it turning it's interesting, I think...