I love the Silent Hill Series. The new games did nothing wrong whatsoever, they were developed well, and did things different. I believe that Silent Hill Downpour will make all Silent Hill fans happy. Team Silent doesn't exist, but their series does.
It was a tie between Simian and the Winged Beastie Things. The wings got my vote as for a time playing it, I'd get freaked expecting the flapping sound to begin. But it isn't so much the flapping that bothers me, it's the crunching grinding sounds you hear after the flapping.