Silent Hill 2 is ultimately my favourite, then it was a close tie between The Room and Silent Hill, but I've decided that I really like the bizarre dreamlike quality of The Room. And lastly, I don't like Heather.
Yeah - 2,1,3 & 4 for me too. I originally loved SH1 more as the music and atmosphere were so extreme. But as I delved deeper into the psychology behind 2, I began to realise some strong connections between the storyline and me. *Frantically stuffs his pillow into a bin*
I voted 2,1,3,4, as well. Didn't finish 4, and while I liked Heather, the game 3 just wasn't as fun or well-crafted to me. 1 and 2 would be about equal, but I do prefer that 2 has a more comprehensible plot and more emotional resonance. I might say 1 was the scariest, but I already talked about that in another thread.