Stop me if you've heard this before... but I never got a good, clear look at who was in the other passing cage during that whole, "Nightmare Jail" sequence. You know the one, when Murphy is riding in that cage along a track, and he's witnessing prison riots, people hanging from rafters, wheels goes by at some point, and then it ends at "his stop", the showers. Another passing cage goes by at some point during the hell ride, and Murphy says something like "Wait... was that? Couldn't be...."
Who is in there? My speculations are on JP Sater, but it's too dark for me to really make out any defining characteristics!
yeah its actually murphy ^^ at first when i was playing the game for my own very first time i thought it was frank in there the beginning !! XD then when when i played many many times ..it turned out its murphy!o.o.. i was like ..what the!?! xD
"I've seen things you people wouldn't believe. [laughs] Attack ships on fire off the shoulder of Orion. I watched c-beams glitter in the dark near the Tannhäuser Gate. All those moments will be lost in time, like [coughs] tears in rain. Time to die."
yeah your right!.. he did! he just seen him self twice! the first one was in the cage and in the second that gloomy prison room of his...when he tried to mention his wife there carol!O_O... so does that means he is crazy or just having these illusions or what?!:/....i mean to see him self!o.o..
I've noticed a lot of the Silent Hills seem to feature that doppelganger essence... (Henry's Victim-self, Memory of Alessa, the corpses around town looking like James, ice sculptures in SHSM looking like Harry) It's extremely unsettling.
your saying is exactly right! but why murphy ...!?O_O.. you see....all of those who you mentioned already can only see them self's with fear and scary looking ..i mean they see them self's like hell inside of them... Heather seen her self as bloody face! Henry seen him self as a scary ghost or something really creepy! James seen a died body! and they can seen them self like this way over and over...while murphy here can't see him self with a scary looking or something O_O! ...just him only! in that cage ..just normally him! O_O...