Silent Hill 2 - 85 on G4's Greatest Video Games of All Time!

[GreyChild]

Video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ehfqq5tm ... 0EFC890A31

They show Silent Hill 2 at 32:45 in the video.

[Mothersdecent]

Deserved to be higher honestly but at least it made it to the list.
I wonder if SH1's gonna get a higher spot?

[OneFreeMan]

Who care's about list. SH2 is one of my favorite games and that's all I really care about.

[GreyChild]

Deserved to be higher honestly but at least it made it to the list.
I wonder if SH1's gonna get a higher spot?

SH1 didnt make it, only SH2, which kinda sucks. SH2 deserves to be higher, though, I agree

[Purramid_Head]

The problem is that "all time" we haven't seen "all time". The future hasn't been written yet. So, better games could come out still.

I'm not a wash over 2 not being higher. These types of lists ("all time") tend to be full of shit anyway.

[Axiomatic]

The problem is that "all time" we haven't seen "all time". The future hasn't been written yet. So, better games could come out still.

I'm not a wash over 2 not being higher. These types of lists ("all time") tend to be full of shit anyway.

^ This. But all things considered, I think it's awesome for it be on the list, but I don't pay attention to where it placed exactly.

[GreyChild]

The problem is that "all time" we haven't seen "all time". The future hasn't been written yet. So, better games could come out still.

I'm not a wash over 2 not being higher. These types of lists ("all time") tend to be full of shit anyway.

^ This. But all things considered, I think it's awesome for it be on the list, but I don't pay attention to where it placed exactly.

Well I do. I like to see what other companies, specially big companies, think of the SH franchise. Im glad it made a greatest games list.

[Axiomatic]

Well I do. I like to see what other companies, specially big companies, think of the SH franchise. Im glad it made a greatest games list.

Maybe I didn't make myself clear.

I do care that the game got onto a greatest games list. That's awesome.

I don't care where exactly the game placed in the rankings, whether it be 85, 67, etc. I think it's a great honor to place on a greatest games list, but I don't want to pay too much attention to the particular ranking because that's a lot less informative to me, and there are issues that might prevent SH2 placing higher: other games, biases for other games, biases against horror games, etc.

[gustavopi]

It's hard to make a list, even harder to define a position to a game. Be in the list is already great, the position is a detail. What's best: SH or RE?

When I see a list like this, sometimes SH1 is on, sometimes SH2. Both together is rare, don't know why. SH1 did the innovation and SH2 is a unique game, it's hard to pick only one. IMO both got to be on the list, like RE1 and RE4.

[Mothersdecent]

Deserved to be higher honestly but at least it made it to the list.
I wonder if SH1's gonna get a higher spot?

SH1 didnt make it, only SH2, which kinda sucks. SH2 deserves to be higher, though, I agree

Yeah, shame.